June 22, 2025

The Church Has A Lying Problem

BY Rev. Heather
Kenny Eliason Unspash

“I know you lie, your lips are moving. Baby, do you think I’m dumb?”

That Meghan Trainor lyric has been on repeat in my brain for days. And honestly? It’s more than just a catchy hook. It’s a gut punch. Because it feels like a mirror—reflecting back everything that’s wrong with what the Church has become in America today.

As a child, I was taught one of the most sacred commandments:

“Thou shalt not lie.”

We were told to be honest, no matter what. Even if it hurt. Even if it got you in trouble. Because truth mattered. Lying, I was told, could send you straight to hell.

So imagine how it feels now, watching those same people who raised me to tell the truth—lie. Boldly. Shamelessly. Repeatedly. All in the name of politics and power. Even worse, in the name of God.

When the Church Echoes Falsehoods

Last week, I posted a solemn video. No words—just me sitting in grief while the audio of a child screaming played in the background. The sound came from a real moment: ICE agents tearing a family apart.

Within hours, MAGA influencers had a new lie ready: they claimed the audio came from an old movie. No evidence. No source. Just a convenient excuse to dismiss human suffering. Another deflection to protect a broken system.

But this isn’t an isolated incident.

We all saw the president’s birthday parade. Empty bleachers. Weak turnout. Tanks rolling by with squeaky wheels. It was underwhelming by every measure. But MAGA’s response?

“Thousands were there! It was historic! The media is lying!”

Even when the evidence is plain and visible, the lie gets louder. And too often, the Church joins in or stays silent.

When the Lies Turn Deadly

This week, tragedy hit Minnesota. State Senator Jason Rarick was murdered. State Representative Joe McDonald was seriously injured in what Governor Tim Walz called a politically motivated assassination attempt.

The suspect? Vance Luther Boelter—a right-wing evangelical pastor and lifelong registered Republican.

And yet, before the blood had even dried, MAGA voices began rewriting the narrative—calling him a Democrat. No facts. Just fiction to avoid accountability.

This is no longer about political spin. It’s about moral collapse. It’s about how lies are killing people—literally and spiritually.

When the President Lies—and the Church Cheers

Then there’s the man at the center of it all: Donald Trump. The Church called him “God’s chosen one.” They waved Bibles. They preached his virtues. And they ignored his endless stream of lies:

  • He lied about the size of his inauguration crowd.
  • He lied about the dangers of COVID-19.
  • He lied about the 2020 election and incited an insurrection.
  • He lied about hush money payments, classified documents, and business fraud.
  • He held up a Bible for a photo op after tear-gassing peaceful protesters—and couldn’t even name a single Bible verse when asked.

And through it all, the Church remained loyal. Not to truth. Not to Jesus. But to him.

Facts Over Feelings… Until the Facts Hurt

Let’s not forget—during Trump’s presidency, MAGA was all about “facts over feelings.”

They mocked liberals for being “too emotional.” They claimed to be the party of truth and logic. But now? That slogan is dead. Because the moment the facts don’t serve them, they deny them.

  • Audio of a suffering child? “Fake news.”
  • Empty bleachers at a parade? “Photoshop.”
  • A MAGA supporter commits murder? “Must be a Democrat.”

It’s not about facts anymore. It’s about defending the illusion. And when the Church echoes that, it does real damage—not just to public discourse, but to the image of God itself.

The Curse of Dishonesty in the Church

The Church has a lying problem. A deep, chronic, soul-wounding problem.

When pastors lie to defend power…
When congregants parrot conspiracy theories instead of compassion…
When Christians distort reality to stay politically comfortable…

We lose our witness. We lose our salt. We lose our light.

Jesus didn’t manipulate. He didn’t deceive. He didn’t tell people what they wanted to hear to stay popular. He told the truth—even when it got him killed.

He said, “Let your yes be yes and your no be no.”
He said the truth would set us free.

But today’s Church often trades truth for tribalism—and calls it “faith.”

What’s at Stake

This isn’t just about politics. This is about who we are as people of faith. It’s about our moral core. It’s about whether anyone outside the Church will ever take us seriously again.

Every time we choose a lie to stay comfortable, we erode our credibility. We betray the Gospel. We wound the people we were called to love.

The world doesn’t need a Church that covers up its hypocrisy with a hymnal. The world needs a Church that can repent. A Church that tells the truth—even when it hurts. Especially when it hurts.

Final Thoughts

So no—I’m not dumb.

I see the lies.
I hear the spin.
I know this isn’t the way of Jesus.

To the Church: your lying isn’t just political—it’s spiritual. It’s a moral failure. And it’s killing your witness.

To the truth-seekers and the deconstructors:
You’re not crazy.
You’re not alone.
Jesus is still real—even if his Church has lost its way.

If the Church wants to survive, it has to stop lying.
It has to repent.
It has to return to the truth.

Because without truth, what’s left?

Just lips moving.
And no one believing a word we say.


Want more reflections like this?

Subscribe here so you never miss a post.
You can also check out my links to support my work and follow me on other socials—where I continue more conversations about faith, truth, and accountability.

This work matters. Let’s keep going. Together.

Heather is a Reverend, writer, and podcast host who ministers to the unchurched, questioning, and deconstructing. After decades in religious spaces, she now walks alongside those who are finding their own way outside the walls, beyond the dogma, and into something truer.
Share

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Copyright © 2025 The Quollective. All Rights Reserved | Designed by Wild & Free Services

    Join The Quollective to read this story.

    No ads. Just stories that matter. Support community voices and help us build a space where every story is seen, heard, and valued.
    ← Back to homepage