May 27, 2026

THE MACHINE | Post 3: The Script How Women Are Taught to Perform Submission

BY Rev. Heather
Kelly Sikkema/Unsplash

Before a girl knows what she believes, she knows how to behave.

She knows to sit a certain way. To speak a certain way. To want certain things and not others. To take up a certain amount of space — which is to say, not much. She knows which emotions are acceptable and which ones make the adults in the room uncomfortable. She knows that her body is a subject of conversation among people who are not her. She knows, without anyone ever saying it plainly, that how she is perceived matters more than who she actually is.

She hasn’t read a theology textbook. She hasn’t sat through a systematic theology course. She is seven, maybe eight years old.

But she has already learned her lines.

That is The Script. And it is handed to girls long before they are old enough to audition for a different role.


Who Wrote It

The Script didn’t appear out of nowhere. It was authored — slowly, deliberately, across centuries — by theologians and pastors and church fathers who were themselves products of the same patriarchal world they were helping to construct.

It was written into sermons and catechisms. Into conduct manuals and devotional literature. Into the architecture of the home and the architecture of the church. It was passed from mother to daughter not as oppression but as wisdom — this is how you survive, this is how you thrive, this is how you please God and keep the peace.

By the time it reached us it no longer felt like a script at all. It felt like nature. Like common sense. Like the obvious shape of a faithful woman’s life.

That is the genius of The Script: it doesn’t announce itself as a script. It announces itself as virtue.


The Three Acts

Act One: Purity Culture

In purity culture, a woman’s value is located in her body — specifically in its sexual history, or lack thereof. She is taught that her purity is a gift she carries for her future husband, that her body is a source of temptation for men and therefore a problem to be managed, that her worth is conditional on behaviors she must perform and boundaries she must enforce — while simultaneously being told that men’s failure to control themselves is, at least in part, her responsibility.

The language is always framed as protection. As honor. As love.

But protection that requires the protected person to make themselves smaller is not protection. It is control with better branding.

Act Two: Modesty Theology

Modesty theology is purity culture’s dress code — but it runs deeper than hemlines. It is a theology of female invisibility. Cover yourself so you don’t distract. Soften your voice so you don’t intimidate. Dim your confidence so you don’t threaten. Be beautiful but not too beautiful. Be smart but don’t show off. Be present but don’t dominate.

The modest woman, in this framework, is a woman who has learned to edit herself continuously — to run every impulse through the filter of how it will land on the men around her. Her inner life is always secondary to its effect on others.

She is not taught to ask who am I? She is taught to ask how am I being perceived?

Act Three: The Helpmeet Framework

Genesis 2:18 — “It is not good for man to be alone; I will make a helper suitable for him.” From this single verse, an entire theology of female purpose was constructed.

The helpmeet framework teaches that a woman’s primary calling is to support, assist, and complete a man. Her gifts exist in service of his vision. Her leadership exists in service of his leadership. Her voice exists to amplify his. She is not the protagonist of her own story. She is the supporting character in his.

This framework doesn’t just shape marriage. It shapes everything — how women relate to male pastors, male employers, male authority of any kind. It trains women to make themselves useful rather than visible, to find their identity in their function rather than their personhood.

And it does all of this while calling it sacred.


What Happens When You Go Off Script

The women who deviate from The Script know what happens.

They are called difficult. Rebellious. Jezebel. Too much. Not submitted. Proud. Unbroken. They are told they have a spirit of independence, which in this context is not a compliment. They are prayed over, counseled, discipled back toward compliance — and if none of that works, they are quietly marginalized until they either conform or leave.

The Script is not just a set of expectations. It is an enforcement system. The community itself becomes the mechanism — watching, evaluating, applying gentle and not-so-gentle pressure toward conformity.

Most women don’t even realize they’re performing. The performance became identity so long ago that there’s no clear line between the role and the self. One of the most disorienting parts of deconstruction is the moment you realize you don’t actually know which parts of you are you and which parts were written for you by a system with an agenda.

That excavation — finding yourself underneath The Script — is some of the most important and most grueling work a person can do.


Rewriting

Here is what I want to say to anyone who is in the middle of that excavation:

The Script was not revelation. It was not the voice of God. It was the voice of a system that needed you manageable, predictable, and small — and it dressed that need in the language of holiness because that was the most effective costume available.

Your anger is not rebellion. It is information.
Your ambition is not pride. It is calling.
Your voice is not too much. It is exactly enough.

The Script handed to you was never the truest thing about you. It was a role written by people who needed you to play it.

You don’t have to anymore.


This is Post 3 of “The Machine” — a series naming the structures that keep patriarchal religion in motion. New posts drop every week. If this resonated with you, share it with someone who needs to hear it.

Heather is a Reverend, writer, and podcast host who ministers to the unchurched, questioning, and deconstructing. After decades in religious spaces, she now walks alongside those who are finding their own way outside the walls, beyond the dogma, and into something truer.
Share

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Copyright © 2025 The Quollective. All Rights Reserved | Designed by Wild & Free Services

    Join The Quollective to read this story.

    No ads. Just stories that matter. Support community voices and help us build a space where every story is seen, heard, and valued.
    ← Back to homepage