May 6, 2025

Preserving Democracy in the Face of Fascism: A Call to Action

BY Matthew Distefano
Image Source

As we face an uncertain future in the United States, a recent episode of the Heretic Happy Hour podcast delved into the troubling implications of the incoming administration and how individuals can navigate the political terrain with hope, resilience, and strategic action. Here, I want to distill some of the most urgent lessons from that conversation.

Understanding the Stakes: The Present Threats to Democracy

The panelists began by assessing the current state of U.S. governance. The alarming truth? All three branches of government—executive, legislative, and judicial—are either captured or vulnerable to extremist ideologies, such as Christian nationalism. As Lisa Sharon Harper noted, this shift is more than a political realignment; it’s a direct assault on democracy itself. She aptly described it as a deliberate effort to dismantle foundational rights, including reproductive freedoms, civil rights protections, and even the concept of birthright citizenship.

Such systemic erosion isn’t coincidental—it’s the culmination of decades-long strategies by groups like the Heritage Foundation, intent on reshaping American governance to entrench wealth and power among a select few. As the panelists pointed out, the recent elections show how deeply entrenched this ideology has become in the electorate, with a majority willing to overlook Donald Trump’s authoritarian tendencies.

The Role of Exhaustion and Disillusionment

Disillusionment and burnout are the enemies of effective resistance. It’s hard not to feel the weight of constant attacks on marginalized communities—be it LGBTQ+ rights, immigrant protections, or the rights of Black Americans. Sandhya Jha, a pastor and activist, spoke about the psychological toll on individuals and how vital it is to find moments of rest and recalibration.

But there’s a caveat: rest cannot become retreat. As Matthew J. DiStefano reminded us, marginalized communities—particularly Black women—have borne the brunt of systemic oppression for centuries. If they can persevere, so can we. The key lies in understanding our individual capacity for resistance and using it wisely.

Local Action: The Key to National Change

The conversation also emphasized the importance of local organizing. Change doesn’t begin in Washington—it starts in our neighborhoods, school boards, and city councils. Sandhya pointed to the example of the Heritage Foundation’s long-term strategy: starting small, building momentum, and eventually influencing national policy.

In the same vein, Harper highlighted the power of faith-rooted organizing to mobilize communities. Her organization, Freedom Road, offers training in this method, focusing on empowering individuals to engage in the public square with integrity and impact. Such grassroots movements can counterbalance the dangerous narratives pushed by extremists.

The Long Game: Learning from History

To truly resist fascism, we must study the past. Harper drew inspiration from movements in South Africa and Serbia, where nonviolent resistance dismantled authoritarian regimes. The lessons? Focus on economic pressure points and exploit the ego of authoritarian leaders. These strategies, while seemingly simple, have proven effective against powerful regimes.

Equally important is preserving collective memory. Harper warned that one of the first acts of authoritarian governments is erasing history to manipulate future narratives. Whether it’s safeguarding cultural artifacts, documenting the present, or simply talking about the world as it is, we must commit to preserving truth.

Intersectionality in Resistance

One of the podcast’s most poignant moments came when DiStefano reflected on the interconnectedness of oppression. Fascism doesn’t target one group—it undermines the humanity of all marginalized people. This reality underscores the importance of intersectionality: our struggles may differ, but they are deeply intertwined. Whether you’re advocating for racial justice, LGBTQ+ rights, or immigrant protections, your work contributes to the broader fight against oppression.

Actionable Steps for the Next Four Years

Doug Pagitt offered a pragmatic perspective: resistance is a long-term commitment, and we must focus on what we can do right now. Here are some key takeaways from the panel:

  1. Speak Up: Silence is complicity. Whether on social media, in your workplace, or with friends, normalize conversations about justice and call out harmful ideologies.
  2. Support Vulnerable Communities: Assess your resources and determine how you can help those at risk—be it financial support, offering shelter, or simply amplifying their voices.
  3. Get Involved Locally: From attending city council meetings to joining activist groups, local engagement creates ripples that lead to national change.
  4. Preserve Memory: Document the present and hold onto cultural artifacts that remind us of who we are and what we value.
  5. Learn from History: Study successful resistance movements to understand what strategies work and adapt them to our unique context.

Conclusion: A Hopeful Resistance

While the road ahead may seem daunting, hope lies in collective action. As Harper eloquently put it, the fight isn’t just for ourselves but for the most vulnerable among us. Whether it’s protecting immigrants, standing with LGBTQ+ communities, or addressing systemic racism, the work we do now will shape the future for generations to come.

The time for action is now. So take stock of your skills, passions, and resources, and join the movement. Together, we can resist—and rebuild—a democracy that truly reflects the common good.

(To listen to the Heretic Happy Hour, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and don’t forget to check them out live every Sunday at 10 AM PST.)

Matthew J. Distefano is an award-winning author, best known for The Wisdom of Hobbits and Mimetic Theory & Middle-earth. He is the co-host of the popular Heretic Happy Hour podcast, co-owner of Quoir Publishing, and owner of Happy Woods Farm—a small permaculture farm nestled in the Sierra Nevada foothills of California. Matthew's thought-provoking work explores spirituality, theology, philosophy, politics, and culture, and his writing has been featured in Sojourners, Patheos, and beyond. He is a graduate of Chico State University, and when he's not writing, farming, or playing The Last of Us, he enjoys spending time with his wife and daughter.
Share

Related Articles

Comments are closed

    Copyright © 2025 The Quollective. All Rights Reserved | Designed by Wild & Free Services

    Join The Quollective to read this story.

    No ads. Just stories that matter. Support community voices and help us build a space where every story is seen, heard, and valued.
    ← Back to homepage